The short version
- A detour is worth it when the saving on the fuel is more than the cost of the extra miles.
- The saving is the price difference in pence × litres bought ÷ 100.
- The cost of the detour is the extra miles × your fuel cost per mile.
- Part-fills and small price gaps rarely justify a detour. A full tank and a bigger gap often do.
- The best saving needs no detour: choose a station on your route.
Two sums to compare
Driving to a cheaper station is a trade. You gain by paying less per litre, and you lose by burning fuel on the extra miles. If the gain is bigger than the loss, you are ahead. Both sides can be worked out in a minute, and once you know your own cost per mile you can reuse the same figure every time the question comes up.
- The saving: price difference in pence × litres you will buy ÷ 100, in pounds.
- The cost of the detour: extra miles driven × your fuel cost per mile.
- The net gain: saving minus cost. If it is positive, the detour pays.
The extra miles are the miles on top of the journey you would have made anyway, not the full distance to the station. If the cheaper station is a few minutes' detour on the way to work, only the added distance counts, and it can be very little.
A worked example
You are about to buy 40 litres. A station on your route sells at 142p a litre. Another, 3 miles off your route, sells at 136p. That is a 6p difference, so the saving is 6 × 40 ÷ 100 = £2.40.
The detour adds 6 miles, three there and three back. If your car does 45 MPG and fuel is around 140p a litre, the fuel cost per mile is about 14p, so 6 miles costs about 85p. The net gain is roughly £1.55. It is positive, but small. If you value your time at more than a few pounds an hour, the extra ten minutes may not be worth it.
| Price difference | Saving | Detour cost | Net gain |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2p | £0.80 | £0.84 | -£0.04 |
| 4p | £1.60 | £0.84 | £0.76 |
| 6p | £2.40 | £0.84 | £1.56 |
| 10p | £4.00 | £0.84 | £3.16 |
A rule of thumb
A handy way to think about it: divide the saving by your cost per mile and you get the number of extra miles you can drive before the saving is gone. A saving of £2.40 at 14p a mile breaks even at about 17 extra miles of detour. In practice you want to stay well inside that, because it ignores your time and the wear on the car.
Two things push the break-even point down. A smaller fill means a smaller saving, so topping up 15 litres rarely justifies any detour. A thirstier car or a congested route raises the cost per mile. Two things push it up. A bigger tank or van, and a bigger price gap, both raise the saving.
The best saving needs no detour
The cheapest litre is the one that is on your route anyway. Before you drive anywhere special, look at the stations along the way you already travel: on the way to work, near the shops, or on a long trip. The journey planner on the live map finds the cheapest stations along a route, so you do not need to leave it.
Station type matters here too. Supermarkets are often cheaper in a local area and motorway services usually dearer, as covered in supermarket, forecourt or motorway: who is cheapest. On a long motorway journey, leaving the motorway for the nearest supermarket forecourt can save more than the exit costs. Check your own city's page, such as Leeds or Glasgow, to see how wide the gap is today. Our city pages show the cheapest station next to the median price, and that gap is the most a good choice can save you there.
Pitfalls to avoid
- Do not run the tank very low just to reach a cheaper station. Running out of fuel costs far more than any saving, and can damage the car.
- Always check the price at the pump. A listed price may have changed since the station last reported it.
- Compare the same fuel: E10 against E10, or diesel against diesel, not premium against standard.
- Count the whole trip. If the cheaper station is in the opposite direction from where you are heading, the extra miles are double the distance.
- Queues, stop-start traffic and a poor route can eat up the saving, so consider the time as well as the money.
Let the numbers decide
If you would rather not do the arithmetic each time, the detour calculator takes the price at both stations, how much you will buy and the extra distance, then tells you whether the trip is worth it. You can work out your own fuel cost per mile with our guide to your car's cost per mile, and see what any gap is worth over a year in how much a 1p difference saves.
Prices on this site are indicative. Always check the price at the pump, and your handbook for the fuel your car needs.