The short version
- The fair comparison is cost per mile, not price per litre.
- Diesel engines are generally more efficient, so a diesel car usually returns more MPG than a similar petrol one.
- The price gap between petrol and diesel moves over time, so check the live prices.
- Diesel tends to suit high-mileage and long-distance driving. Petrol often suits shorter trips.
- Cost per mile is only part of the picture: purchase price, tax and servicing matter too.
Price per litre is the wrong comparison
It is natural to look at the two prices on the forecourt sign and pick the lower. But a litre of petrol and a litre of diesel do not take you the same distance, because the fuels and the engines that burn them are different. What matters is how much it costs to travel a mile, which depends on both the price and the MPG.
Diesel contains more energy per litre than petrol, and diesel engines tend to convert more of it into movement. As a result, a diesel car is usually able to cover more miles on a litre than a comparable petrol car. That can offset a higher pump price. It can also fail to, if the price gap is wide or the diesel model is less efficient than it looks.
The sum that settles it
For each car, work out the fuel cost per mile: price per litre in pence × 4.546 ÷ MPG. Our guide to working out your car's cost per mile walks through it. Then compare the two figures.
| Petrol car | Diesel car | |
|---|---|---|
| Price per litre | 140p | 150p |
| Real-world MPG | 45 | 55 |
| Fuel cost per mile | 14.1p | 12.4p |
| Fuel cost for 10,000 miles | £1,414 | £1,240 |
In this example diesel is dearer by 10p a litre but still cheaper per mile because of the better MPG. A quick test is to multiply the petrol car's MPG by the ratio of the two prices. Here that is 45 × 150 ÷ 140, or about 48. If the diesel car does better than 48 MPG at those prices, it is cheaper to run on fuel alone.
Change the prices and the answer can flip. If diesel were 25p dearer than petrol, the diesel car would need a much higher MPG to come out ahead. This is why it is worth using today's figures: the petrol vs diesel calculator fills in the live pump prices and compares the yearly cost, including an electric car if you are weighing that up too.
Why the diesel price gap moves
Petrol and diesel are taxed in the same way, with a fixed duty per litre and VAT on top, as we explain in how much tax is in a litre of petrol. So most of the difference between them comes from the wholesale market and from demand, not from the tax. Diesel is also used by lorries, vans, buses and trains, so its price can move differently from petrol when freight demand or supply changes. Our guide to why petrol prices change covers what moves the cost of the fuel itself.
The practical point is that the gap is not fixed. Compare petrol and diesel on the live map and on your own city's page, such as London or Manchester, before you assume which is cheaper.
How you drive changes the answer
Diesel cars tend to suit drivers who cover many miles, particularly on motorways and A roads, where the engine runs warm and steady. Many modern diesels have a particulate filter that needs a sustained run at speed to clear itself, and regular short, cold trips are not what it is designed for. Petrol cars generally cope better with short journeys and town driving.
If most of your driving is a few miles at a time, the diesel's MPG advantage may not show up in practice, and a petrol car or a hybrid might serve you better. If you do tens of thousands of miles a year, an efficient diesel can still make sense. Your handbook and a garage can tell you how your particular car should be driven.
Beyond the fuel
Fuel cost per mile is not the whole bill. Diesel cars have often cost more to buy than the equivalent petrol model, and tax can differ by car and by the year it was registered, so check the vehicle tax rate tables for the cars you are comparing. Some city clean-air schemes set emissions standards that older diesels may not meet, so check the rules where you drive before you buy.
Servicing and repair costs also vary by model, not simply by fuel type. A used-car history check and the MOT record on GOV.UK help you judge what a particular car has cost to keep on the road.
How to decide
- Find the real-world MPG of each car you are considering, not just the official figure.
- Look up today's petrol and diesel prices near you.
- Work out the fuel cost per mile and the cost over your yearly mileage.
- Add vehicle tax, insurance, servicing and the purchase price.
- Think about the journeys you actually make, short or long.
If you already own a car, the question is simply which grade and station give you the lowest cost per mile, and our guide to E10, E5 and diesel explains the grades on the pump.
Prices on this site are indicative. Always check the price at the pump, and your handbook for the fuel your car needs.